Skip to content
VietVance

Site search

Science & Technology

Apple to Stand Trial in France in 2027 Over Alleged Obstruction of iPhone Repairs

Plaintiff HOP says Paris prosecutors have decided to bring a case against Apple over alleged obstruction of iPhone repairs, with a trial expected in 2027. The dispute concerns component pairing across 24 iPhone models. Apple denies the allegations, saying the system protects device security, privacy and performance.

VietVance

2 min read

Plaintiff HOP said on November 17, 2026, that Paris prosecutors had decided to bring a case against Apple over alleged obstruction of iPhone repairs before the Paris Criminal Court. The trial will take place in 2027. The allegations concern 24 iPhone models and conduct between November 2021 and July 2024. This is the first time a company in France has been prosecuted for allegedly obstructing repairs.

An Apple logo inside a store in Tokyo, Japan.(VietVance)

At the center of the dispute is a technique that pairs components with a device’s serial number: parts such as screens, batteries and cameras are linked to the device’s serial number through chips. HOP says that when a repairer outside Apple’s authorized network replaces a part, some phone functions may stop working or become limited, even if the replacement is a genuine part. The organization argues that this makes users dependent on Apple’s repair services and limits access to lower-cost repairs.

HOP says replacing the screen on some newer iPhone models can cost up to 489 euros (about $537.62), while the average smartphone repair in France costs about 161 euros. Apple denies obstructing independent repairs. It says component pairing helps calibrate parts, keep features such as Face ID, Touch ID and True Tone working properly, and prevent parts from stolen devices from being reused. The company also points to a support program for independent repairers launched in 2019 and a self-service repair program introduced in April 2022.

A key question in the case is how the court will assess Apple’s intent. Under the applicable French law, the court must determine whether Apple deliberately obstructed independent repairs; showing only that component pairing made repairs more difficult for outside repairers would not be enough. Because the alleged conduct took place between 2021 and 2024, the court will apply the French law in force at that time.

A directive adopted by the European Union in 2024 prohibits manufacturers from using technical or software measures to obstruct product repairs. Member states were required to incorporate the rules into national law by July 31, 2026. France has yet to do so and received a warning from the European Commission in September 2026.

Source: VietVance

Related