Hanoi apartment case: Prosecutors explain why only five officials face charges
At the trial over violations at the CT6 Kiến Hưng apartment project, defense lawyers questioned why only five former local officials face criminal charges when other projects linked to Lê Thanh Thản’s businesses were also found to have violations. Prosecutors said other cases require sufficient evidence. The court is expected to announce its ruling on November 26.
A Hanoi court has begun deliberations after hearing the case involving the CT6 Kiến Hưng project. Lê Thanh Thản, former chairman of Tập đoàn Mường Thanh, is charged with deceiving customers. Five former local officials are charged with negligence causing serious consequences for failing to detect and stop violations at the project. Defense lawyers cited 12 projects linked to his businesses that Hanoi authorities had identified as having violations and questioned why only officials involved in this project faced criminal charges.
Prosecutors said each project must be handled separately based on the evidence; if competent authorities establish other criminal conduct in the future, it can still be prosecuted. They said conduct involving construction regulations, tax and land management at CT6 Kiến Hưng did not meet the requirements for separate criminal charges. Lê Thanh Thản is charged with deceiving customers for selling 519 apartments built in violation of the approved plan through misleading advertising.

Hanoi prosecutors at the trial.(VietVance)
Addressing the lawyers’ questions about senior officials’ responsibility, prosecutors said the available evidence was insufficient to bring criminal charges against the district leaders concerned. They said there was no record of ward officials or construction inspectors reporting the project’s violations to district leaders and requesting action. Although the five defendants had attempted to enter the construction site to inspect it, they did not follow through, and ward officials and inspectors shifted responsibility between them.
Regarding the VND 531 billion paid by 519 homebuyers, prosecutors said the consequences of negligence also included damage to public trust in state authorities, but they did not seek to hold the five former officials jointly liable for compensation. Prosecutors said a newly issued Hanoi resolution allows 440 families who bought apartments built in violation of regulations to remain in their homes and complete ownership paperwork, while providing relocation support for the remaining 79 households. Prosecutors asked the court to order Lê Thanh Thản and his company, Công ty Bemes, to compensate residents at market prices of VND 53 million to VND 56 million per square meter. The court is expected to announce its sentencing and compensation rulings on the afternoon of November 26.

Lê Thanh Thản and five former local officials appeared in court on November 19.(VietVance)
Source: VietVance


