Skip to content
VietVance

Site search

State-owned Enterprises

Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industries Group Found to Have Financial and Mining Violations

Vietnam’s Government Inspectorate found that four of six coal companies examined under TKV exceeded their permitted annual mining capacity between 2020 and 2024. It also identified delayed payments to the state budget, undistributed subsidiary dividends and issues with resource tax calculations, and called for a review of responsibility.

VietVance

2 min read

Vietnam’s Government Inspectorate has released its findings on the management of state capital and assets at the Vietnam Coal and Mineral Industries Group (TKV). An inspection of 13 mine sites operated by six of the group’s coal companies found that four exceeded the annual capacity specified in their mining licenses between 2020 and 2024. Each exceedance was below 15% and violated the Mineral Law. Công ty Than Uông Bí - TKV exceeded its permitted output at the Đồng Vông mine by 10.71% in 2022. At the Mạo Khê underground mine, Công ty Than Mạo Khê - TKV exceeded its permitted output by 7.5% in 2020, 4.96% in 2021 and 8.68% in 2022.

The inspection also found problems with TKV’s pricing of coal and copper sales and its trademark fees. Because the parent company set aside more than permitted for financial investment provisions in 2021, it was required to pay more than VND 129 billion in remaining profit to the state budget. It did not declare and pay the amount until 2023, and the late-payment amount for 2021–2022 has yet to be determined or paid. Between 2020 and 2024, eight subsidiaries did not fully distribute their after-tax profits, leaving more than VND 1.987 trillion undistributed by the end of 2024. Based on TKV’s shareholdings, more than VND 1.634 trillion of that amount was due to the group.

Coal industry file photo.(VietVance)

On resource tax, inspectors compared the taxable output reported for coal sold by mining companies to two coal preparation companies between 2020 and 2024 with the companies’ output after preparation. They found a difference of 4,950,278 tonnes. TKV argued that the tax should be calculated using the mining units’ appraisal certificates and transaction prices. The Government Inspectorate said this method did not comply with Ministry of Finance regulations and recommended calculating the tax using the coal obtained after raw coal is processed, TKV’s actual market selling price and the statutory tax rate. Inspectors also found that the group’s minerals corporation underpaid resource tax on iron ore concentrate in 2020–2021 and must pay more than VND 3.9 billion in additional tax.

Mining-related file photo.(VietVance)

The inspection findings also state that nine group branches and three subsidiaries recorded more than VND 70 billion in depreciation on fixed assets above the permitted amount between 2020 and 2024. From 2020 to 2022, the parent company included more than VND 10 billion in land-use fees for a plot in Ho Chi Minh City and a garment factory site in Quảng Ninh Province as tax-deductible expenses. Neither site was in use or generating business activity at the time. The Government Inspectorate recommended that the relevant entities and TKV review the nature, causes and consequences of each issue, determine the responsibility of those involved and take action in accordance with the law.

Source: VietVance

Related